| Date | Result | |
| (Final Statistics) | Box score | |
| November 20, 1999 | No. 7 Notre Dame 68, Toledo 52 | Box score |
| November 22, 1999 | Cleveland State 68, Toledo 57 | Box score |
| November 27, 1999 | Toledo 61, Loyola-Maryland 45 | Box score |
| November 28, 1999 | Vanderbilt 63, Toledo 44 | Box score |
| December 01, 1999 | Indiana State 61, Toledo 58 | Box score |
| December 09, 1999 | Detroit 78, Toledo 74 (OT) | Box score |
| December 15, 1999 | UW-Green Bay 67, Toledo 51 | Box score |
| December 19, 1999 | Toledo 79, Washington State 59 | Box score |
| December 28, 1999 | Youngstown State 75, Toledo 57 | Box score |
| December 30, 1999 | Toledo 57, Duquesne 52 | Box score |
| January 05, 2000 | Western Michigan 67, Toledo 66 (OT) | Box score |
| January 08, 2000 | Toledo 73, Miami 66 | Box score |
| January 11, 2000 | Toledo 83, Bowling Green 63 | Box score |
| January 15, 2000 | Toledo 67, Central Michigan 60 | Box score |
| January 17, 2000 | Toledo 80, Eastern Michigan 52 | Box score |
| January 19, 2000 | Toledo 62, Akron 53 | Box score |
| January 23, 2000 | Ball State 64, Toledo 57 | Box score |
| January 29, 2000 | Kent 73, Toledo 63 | Box score |
| February 03, 2000 | Northern Illinois 61, Toledo 60 | Box score |
| February 05, 2000 | Toledo 83, Ball State 69 | Box score |
| February 09, 2000 | Western Michigan 77, Toledo 70 | Box score |
| February 09, 2000 | Western Michigan 77, Toledo 70 | Box score |
| February 13, 2000 | Toledo 69, Buffalo 68 (OT) | Box score |
| February 19, 2000 | Toledo 86, Central Michigan 64 | Box score |
| February 21, 2000 | Eastern Michigan 91, Toledo 54 | Box score |
| February 23, 2000 | Ohio 62, Toledo 60 | Box score |
| February 25, 2000 | Toledo 70, Northern Illinois 55 | Box score |
| March 04, 2000 | Toledo 81, Ball State 65 | Box score |
| March 04, 2000 | Toledo 64, Western Michigan 55 | Box score |
| March 04, 2000 | Kent 71, Toledo 60 | Box score |